No, I’m actually really kinda heated that they changed Shun’s gender, like a lot.
I’m fucking salty as shit LOL!!
For those of you that think this was done to “include females” characters then you are a fucking idiot. This was done cuz Saint Seiya was introduced as a kid’s show, and I am 100% sure they did this bullshit so they wouldn’t have to explain why someone like Shun is around since he is the complete opposite of what “a guy” should be.
Like fuck off. I 100% understand why this was done in Voltron, because it didn’t matter what gender Pidge was. Pidge wasn’t a character that truly mattered if it was male or female as his gender didn’t bring a specific characteristic to his character.
But in Shun’s side that’s the COMPLETE OPPOSITE. The whole point is that he’s a guy and he’s seen as a coward, a wimp, a bitch, and “girly” just cuz he doesn’t want to fight. He doesn’t like fighting, and yet he can fight and protect himself perfectly well. He wants to protect the people he cares for and wants to be of use even if he can’t fight. The other knights make fun of how girly he is and how he has the armor of a woman and he still doesn’t let that shit bother him because he knows who he is.
On top of that, he’s the character that mostly shows you that it’s okay to need help and depend on others. As he does with his brother A LOT. His brother protected him and also if you take all of this into consideration and twist Shun’s gender into a female, then he just becomes the stereotypical female character that needs to constantly be rescued and helped by men. Which NO ONE WANTS TO SEE.
In other words, they twisted shun’s character to brush under the rug having to explain why a boy that acts “gay” is in a kids show, and also to pamper the audience with a female character that it’s going to be a terrible pick.
They could have picked ANY OTHER KNIGHT to change the gender of. Fuck make his brother, his sister instead. Ikki would have been amazing as a badass bitch or Shiryu, but no, they went for the ONE CHARACTER that was the stupidest decision to pick.
dixdafne said:
@demnocts 30 yrs interview? The oldest interview is from 2015, where he reaffirms his views as he always does, the new manga is written by him and it has the exact same views as the 80’s
Man this was fun while it lasted, but I’m getting sick of you going in circles and putting words in my mouth and accusing me of dumb stuff if you didn’t want people answering to you, you simply should have kept the rant in your blog and not in the fandom tags for all to see 🙄
demnocts said:
@dixdafne and it’s a “call out” as to why their decision fucking blows. They obviously did it to pamper to audience and show they are diverse while not taking any risks so the original fans wouldn’t make that much noise over it since shun has never really been that popular with the male audience but the female audience. They didn’t do anything diverse, they did a power rangers and picked the knight that wears pink. How mind blowing. So different.
demnocts said:
@dixdafne from all your replies all I’m getting from you is that you are discussing this topic with the mindset of another fandom and why you are so defensive over it and acting like creativity directors do things amazingly and well as if that’s always the case. And I get it cuz fandoms like voltron and she-ra are a fucking toxic wasteland of bullshit with fans that harass and attack creators nonstop. But this isn’t the same at all. This is criticism
demnocts said:
@dixdafne so while you are saying “the creator didnt mean that lawl” from like a 30 year old interview and say “he only made a wide cast for people to like one” that contradicts everything you fucking said cuz that means he actually meant for people to view characters differently and also relate to them and find the one that you like. Which it’s something abnormal in shounen. I mean that’s how they usually go, and they have a wide cast.
demnocts said:
@dixdafne it is mediocrity and boring. And considering the fact that I have watched and read all the spin offs of this show obviously I was gonna watch it??? That’s the stupidest thing to say, this show has an old following.
demnocts said:
@dixdafne but their writing translated different or some aspects of it became more relevant in the future because of how media changes and how people and times change. Second you completely ignored how I talked about how they could have genderbend any other character. Like ikki for example. Instead you applauded them for picking the one that wears pink, was already “effeminate” and act kinda “girly”. As if that was an amazing creator’s liberty they took and a risk.
demnocts said:
@dixdafne did I attack a creator? No, i ranted in my own personal tumblr and was like oh I’m salty and i explained why. You were the one that acted like i was personally telling the creators to fuck off. So get off that dumbass mindset. I’m not talking about fucking voltron here. I know damn well how that shit show went. And I was talking about Rowling as an example of how some writers might have meant something/said something but their writing says something else.